Skip to content

A Comparison of Security Groups and Network Access Control Lists in AWS

NACL i SG in AWS cloud 2024

Understanding Network Security in the Cloud: A Comparison of Security Groups and Network Access Control Lists in AWS cloud. In the ever-evolving landscape of cloud computing, ensuring robust security measures is paramount. Among the myriad of tools available, Security Groups (SG) and Network Access Control Lists (NACL) stand out as vital components in managing network access. In this guide, we delve into the intricacies of both SG and NACL, comparing their functionalities, use cases, and best practices.

Network Access Control Lists (NACLs)

Network Access Control Lists, often referred to as NACLs, serve as network-level policies dictating inbound and outbound traffic within a subnet. These policies play a crucial role in filtering traffic, determining what is permissible and what is not. By default, NACLs allow all traffic, emphasizing the importance of configuring them to allow only authorized traffic.

Key Features of NACLs:

  • Rule Structure: NACLs comprise various fields including rule number, type, protocol, port range, source, and allow or deny action.
  • Processing Order: Rules are processed from smallest to largest, with the last rule acting as the default, blocking traffic if no match is found.
  • Stateless Nature: NACLs are stateless, meaning they do not retain information about previously transmitted or received traffic. This necessitates configuring rules meticulously, considering both inbound and outbound traffic requirements.

Practical Application:

NACLs play a vital role in securing communication between different components within a network. By configuring specific rules, one can control traffic flow, ensuring secure connections while mitigating potential threats.

Security Groups (SG)

Security Groups, akin to NACLs, serve as a mechanism for filtering traffic. However, SG operates at the instance level, offering granular control over inbound and outbound traffic. Unlike NACLs, SG is stateful, simplifying the management of traffic flow by automatically permitting return traffic based on the initial request.

Key Features of Security Groups:

  • Stateful Nature: SG retains contextual information, facilitating the automatic allowance of return traffic without additional configuration.
  • Simplified Rule Management: When creating a security group, administrators only need to specify entries that are allowed, streamlining the rule-setting process.
  • Instance-level Filtering: SG operates at the instance level, offering precise control over traffic flow to and from individual instances.

Practical Application:

SGs are ideal for scenarios where granular control over traffic flow is required at the instance level. From hosting web servers to managing database access, SGs provide a flexible and intuitive solution for enforcing security policies.

Comparing Use Cases

While both NACLs and SGs serve as effective means of network security, understanding their respective strengths and use cases is essential.

Use Case 1: Database Access Control

When restricting access to a database, SGs excel in providing granular control based on instance-level specifications. By configuring specific rules within the SG, administrators can precisely define who can access the database, increasing security without limiting access to the entire subnet.

Use Case 2: Subnet-level Traffic Management

In scenarios where managing traffic within subnets is crucial, NACLs offer a comprehensive solution. By configuring rules at the network level, NACLs provide overarching control over traffic flow, ensuring secure communication between various components.

Practical Demonstration

To illustrate the practical implementation of both NACL and SG, I have created a video NACL and Security Group in AWS showing how to create and configure these security measures. Thanks to this video you will see what it looks like in practice:

NACL and Security Group in AWS | 2024


In conclusion, both Security Groups and Network Access Control Lists play pivotal roles in securing cloud infrastructure. By understanding their functionalities, strengths, and use cases, administrators can effectively safeguard their networks against potential threats while facilitating seamless communication within the cloud environment.

If you liked the article, check out others related to AWS. I will also be happy if you share it with others. I encourage you to visit the blog and YouTube channel. I try to publish new content systematically, although sometimes it is difficult and takes a lot of time.

Alarm based on metrics from CloudWatch | EC2 Disk Usage Notifications
How to read and write a file on S3 using lambda function and boto3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *